Pop up drain vs Push down Drain: Which is the Best for Your Sink?
Are you trying to decide between a pop-up drain or a push-down drain for your bathroom sink? Understanding the differences between the two types of drain stoppers can help you make the right choice for your needs.
Are you trying to decide between a pop-up drain or a push-down drain for your bathroom sink? Understanding the differences between the two types of drain stoppers can help you make the right choice for your needs.
The type of sink you have, the size of the drain opening, and the style of your sink faucet can all play a role in determining which type of drain is the best fit.
In this blog post, we’ll go over the main features and benefits of pop-up and push-down drains, including how they function, the materials they’re made of, and their ease of use.
So whether you’re installing a new drain or replacing an old one, read on to learn more about these two popular bathroom sink options.
Table of Contents
Pop up Drain vs Push down Drain: Which Drain Stopper is Right for You?
Cost Comparison
When it comes to cost, pop-up drains tend to be more affordable than push-down drains. In fact, pop-up drains are the more common option on the market, and they typically come with a lower price tag.
For example, lift rod pop-up drains with an overflow can be found starting at around $75.88, while a pop-up drain without overflow may cost nearly $70.34.
However, it’s worth noting that the price can vary depending on the type of metal used in the construction of the drain.
In comparison, a chrome push-down drain, with or without an overflow, tends to be priced higher than a chrome pop-up drain, coming in at around $96.79, which is about $26 more expensive.
So, if cost is a major factor in your decision-making process, it may be worth considering a pop-up drain as a more budget-friendly option.
Ease of Installation Comparison
Regarding installation, push-down drains are generally easier to install than pop-up drains. Push-down drains require no additional assembly, and their installation process is straightforward.
Pop-up drains, on the other hand, require more installation steps, including assembling various parts, which can be time-consuming and more challenging.
If you’re not experienced with plumbing, a push-down drain may be the easier option to install.
Maintenance and Cleaning Comparison
Maintenance and cleaning are critical factors to consider when deciding between a pop-up and a push-down drain.
Push-down drains are relatively easy to clean, and maintenance is minimal. However, they tend to clog more frequently than pop-up drains, which can make cleaning more challenging.
Pop-up drains are easier to clean and maintain, and their parts can be replaced quickly. If you prefer a low-maintenance option, a pop-up drain may be the better choice.
Durability Comparison
Pop-up drains are typically more durable than push-down drains, as their complex design and robust construction make them less prone to damage.
Push-down drains, while more affordable, are often made of lower-quality materials that can wear out quickly.
If you’re looking for a long-lasting option, a pop-up drain may be a better choice.
Aesthetics Comparison
Pop-up drains are typically more aesthetically pleasing than push-down drains, as they offer a sleek and more modern option and look to your sink.
On the other hand, push-down drains are less visible and do not add to the sink’s overall aesthetics. If you’re looking to add a touch of style to your sink, a pop-up drain may be the better option.
Size
The three most common drain sizes are 1 ¼ inch, 1 ½ inch, and 1 ⅝ inch, regardless of whether it’s a pop-up drain or a push-down drain.
The key factor to consider is that the drain must be the same size or smaller than the hole in your sink. If the drain is larger than the hole, it won’t fit properly.
But what about when the drain is smaller than the hole in the sink? It’s a common concern, but it’s not a problem.
The threaded section of the drainpipe must fit in the drain hole, so the drain’s measurement is typically for that purpose. As long as the threaded section fits into the hole, the drain will function properly.
So, if you’re wondering if a pop-up drain will fit in your sink, you just need to measure the drain hole and make sure it’s the same size or smaller than the drain.
This way, you’ll be able to find a suitable drain that will work effectively with your sink.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a sink Drain Type for Your Sink
Sink Type
The type of sink you have plays a significant role in determining which type of drain will work best. For example, a vessel sink typically requires a pop-up drain, while an undermount sink often uses a push-down drain.
It’s important to understand the compatibility of your sink with different drain types before making a final decision.
Sink Location
Another crucial factor to consider is the location of your sink. If your sink is in an area with limited space, such as a small bathroom, a push-down drain may be the better option as it won’t take up as much space as a pop-up drain.
On the other hand, if you have more space and want to add a touch of elegance to your sink, a pop-up drain may be the better choice.
Personal Preferences
Your personal preferences are also essential when choosing a drain type. Do you prefer the sleek, stylish look of a push-down drain or the convenience of a pop-up drain? Would you rather have a drain that is easy to clean or one that requires less maintenance?
These are all important factors to consider when deciding which drain type is the best fit for your needs.
Maintenance Requirements
Finally, consider the maintenance requirements of each sink drain type. Pop-up sink drains may be more convenient to use, but they require more maintenance to keep them functioning properly.
On the other hand, push-down sink drains are simpler to use and require less maintenance, but they may not be as aesthetically pleasing as pop-up drains. Consider your lifestyle and maintenance preferences when deciding which sink drain type is the best fit for you.
How to install sink push pop-up drain stopper
Installing a sink push pop-up drain stopper is a straightforward process that you can easily do yourself. Here’s how:
- To begin the process of replacing a drain, the first step is to remove the old one. This can be achieved by loosening the slip nut that connects the drainpipe to the sink tailpiece. Once the slip nut is loosened, the old drain can be pushed up through the sink.
- Clean the drain opening and the area around it thoroughly.
- Take the new pop-up drain stopper and put the rubber gasket on the bottom of the drain.
- Insert the drain into the opening and tighten the slip nut until the drain is snugly in place.
- Connect the pivot rod to the pop-up assembly and place the assembly into the drain opening.
- Insert the pivot rod into the clevis strap and tighten the screw to secure it.
- Attach the lift rod to the lever located behind the sink faucet.
- Fill the sink with water and check to make sure that the stopper is operating correctly.
By following these steps, you can easily install a sink push pop-up drain stopper and have it functioning properly in no time.
Conclusion
In conclusion, when it comes to choosing between a pop-up drain and a push-down drain, there are a number of factors to consider. Pop-up drains are generally more affordable, easier to install, and easier to clean, while push-down drains offer more options and a sleeker and more modern aesthetic.
If you’re looking for an affordable and easy-to-maintain option, a pop-up sink drain may be the way to go.
However, if you’re willing to spend a little more for a more visually appealing drain, a push-down drain may be a better fit for your needs.
Ultimately, the choice between a pop-up drain and a push-down drain will depend on your individual preferences and needs.
Consider the factors we’ve outlined in this article, including sink type, sink location, personal preferences, budget, and maintenance requirements, to make an informed decision that’s right for you.
FAQ
Are pop up drain stoppers good?
Yes, pop up drain stoppers can be a good choice for sinks as they are easy to operate with just a push or pull, and they offer a sleek and modern look. They can also prevent clogs and keep unwanted debris from going down the drain.
However, it is important to choose a high-quality pop up drain stopper to ensure the proper functioning and avoid any potential issues with leakage or damage.
What is push vs pop-up drain?
A push drain is a type of drain that uses a push button or lever to open and close the drain. A pop-up drain, on the other hand, uses a lift rod or knob to lift a stopper and allow water to flow through the drain.
What is the advantage of a pop-up drain?
One of the advantages of a pop-up drain is that it is easier to use than a push drain because it is operated by a simple lift rod or knob. Pop-up drains also come in a variety of styles and finishes, making them a popular choice for bathroom sinks.
What is a push-up drain?
A push-up drain is another type of drain that is similar to a push drain. It uses a push button or lever to open and close the drain, but instead of pushing the stopper down, it pushes it up to allow water to flow through the drain.
Should the pop-up drain have an overflow?
It is recommended that pop-up drains have an overflow, especially for bathroom sinks, to prevent water from overflowing and causing damage to the surrounding area.
What’s the difference between a pop-up drain with overflow and without overflow?
A pop-up drain with overflow has a small hole located near the top of the sink that allows water to drain if the sink becomes too full. A pop-up sink drain without overflow does not have this hole and is therefore not suitable for sinks that require overflow protection
